Rumor – Video showing widespread destruction and clashes in Paris allegedly occurred right after France’s national team was eliminated by Spain in the World Cup semifinals.
Analysis
The recent and impactful elimination of the French national team by Spain in the World Cup semifinals shook social media far beyond sports discussions regarding on-field performance. Within a few hours, images of allegedly chaotic urban violence and flames engulfing the streets of Paris began circulating on messaging apps and social media platforms, sparking deep concern among international audiences.
In some versions, the videos are accompanied by the claim that “Paris is burning” and that the country is experiencing a security collapse. Other messages claim that hundreds of people were arrested in Paris and Lyon as a result of clashes between fans and police. Read two versions of the story circulating online:
Version 1: Breaking: Paris is burning right now after France’s defeat to Spain in the World Cup semifinals. A few hours earlier, Macron tried to present France as an island of peace during the military parade. This looks like the beginning of a civil war! In video 2, hours earlier, the mockery presented as the French army…
Version 2: After France’s 2-0 defeat to Spain in the World Cup semifinals, scenes of violence erupted in Lyon and Paris. In Lyon, “fans” took to the streets and attacked police officers, launched fireworks at security forces, and committed acts of vandalism, resulting in dozens of arrests. In the French capital, the number of detainees exceeded 140.
Fact Check
Faced with the rapid spread of these visual recordings, we initiated a fact-checking process to clarify three fundamental points: 1) Does the video actually show destruction in Paris after France’s defeat to Spain in the World Cup? 2) What is the real origin of the video showing destruction in Paris? 3) Were there actually protests and arrests after France’s defeat to Spain in the World Cup?
Does the video show destruction in Paris after France’s defeat to Spain in the World Cup?
No. The most widely shared images on social media were not recorded after France’s defeat to Spain. Although isolated episodes of violence did occur following the French elimination, the main video used in the viral posts shows clashes recorded weeks earlier, during the celebrations of Paris Saint-Germain’s (PSG) Champions League victory.
On that occasion, thousands of people took to the streets to celebrate the European title, but part of the celebration ended in clashes with the police, vandalism, and hundreds of arrests. Subsequently, these images were repurposed to falsely depict the aftermath of the French national team’s elimination from the World Cup.
What is the origin of the video showing destruction in Paris?
As mentioned, the main video circulating on social media actually portrays incidents that occurred weeks earlier, during the celebrations and subsequent riots following the Champions League final.
At that time, Paris Saint-Germain’s European title victory prompted thousands of fans to take to the streets of Paris, culminating in outbreaks of vandalism, property damage, and direct clashes with local security forces.
As reported by the international press, police forces made nearly 900 arrests across the country after PSG won the Champions League final. Therefore, the images of flames and heavy police crackdown belong to this prior event and not to the national team’s defeat.
Were there protests and arrests after France’s defeat to Spain in the World Cup?
Yes, there were reports of isolated incidents and minor clashes in French cities after the World Cup semifinal elimination, but on a significantly smaller scale than suggested by alarmist posts. There were episodes of urban disorder, fireworks launched at police forces, and sporadic arrests in both Lyon and Paris.
Media outlets reported that the disturbances in Paris and Lyon after the World Cup defeat occurred at a very moderate level and were controlled by the authorities compared to the scale of the previous Champions League final protests, debunking the narrative that the capital was completely destroyed or on the verge of a civil conflict.
Conclusion
In short, publications using videos of urban destruction to claim that Paris was set on fire due to France’s World Cup defeat are misleading. The most shocking visual material depicts an older Champions League celebration involving PSG fans, while the actual incidents from the World Cup semifinal were far more limited and contained by local security forces.
Fake news ❌
Ps: This article was suggested by readers of our fact-checking platform. If you would like to suggest a topic for verification, please contact us via email or our messaging channels.