Rumor – A video shows a rain of fish that supposedly occurred in Nice, France, after a waterspout.
Analysis
The waterfront of Nice, on the trendy Côte d’Azur, is usually the setting for sunny postcards and calm waters, but recent images have brought an almost biblical tone to the region. Videos showing what appears to be a waterspout dumping hundreds of fish onto the wet asphalt have left internet users speechless at the supposed power of nature on the French coast.
The material quickly crossed borders, accumulating thousands of views under the promise of recording an extremely rare meteorological event. The posts suggest that the weather in France had reached such a point of instability that marine animals were tossed from the ocean directly onto the city streets during a severe storm. Read:
Latest news from Nice: a waterspout makes it rain… fish! – This rare phenomenon explained #france #nice06 #cotedazur #cotedazurfrance #foryou Waterspout in Nice: incredible rain of fish A rare phenomenon in Nice: fish fall from the sky during a storm. Discover the scientific explanation! #france #nice06 #cotedazur Keywords: waterspout, fish rain in Nice, rare meteorological phenomena, storm in Nice, fish falling from the sky, waterspout explanation, weather in France, Nice Côte d’Azur, unusual event, natural curiosities, fish rain videos
Fact-Check
The repercussion of the case raises legitimate doubts about safety and climate phenomena in Europe, requiring a careful verification of the facts. To clarify what happened, we will answer the following questions: 1) Does the video show a rain of fish that occurred in Nice, France? 2) How was the video showing the rain of fish in Nice made? 3) Is it possible for this to happen?
Does the video show a rain of fish that occurred in Nice, France?
No, the video does not depict a real event that occurred in Nice. Although the captions and hashtags attempt to place the scene in the famous French city, there is no official record from local meteorological agencies or news in French media outlets confirming such a storm. If an event of this magnitude had hit the Côte d’Azur, there would be hundreds of other angles recorded by residents and tourists, as well as Civil Defense alerts, which did not happen.
How was the video showing the rain of fish in Nice made?
The video in question is a product of generative artificial intelligence. By analyzing the images in detail, it is possible to notice inconsistencies in the physics of the objects and, most importantly, the presence of watermarks indicating the use of Sora, OpenAI’s video creation model. It is an extremely realistic digital simulation, but it has no basis in the physical world. The use of AI to create natural disaster scenarios has become common to generate engagement on social networks like TikTok and Instagram.
Is it possible for this to happen?
Yes, scientifically the phenomenon of “animal rain” is possible, although rare. It usually happens when tornadoes or waterspouts (columns of air rotating over a body of water) suck small animals, such as fish or frogs, into their updrafts. These animals can be transported for miles before being deposited on land along with the precipitation. There are historical reports of this type of event in various places around the world, but in the specific case of this video from Nice, the origin is purely technological and not meteorological.
Conclusion
Although nature is capable of producing surprising events like animal rain, the video circulating about Nice is artificial content created by artificial intelligence (Sora) and does not correspond to the recent climatic reality of France.
Fake news ❌
Ps: This article is a response to reader suggestions. If you want to suggest a topic for a fact-check, please contact our team via email or our official social media channels.